Home » Guide to choosing the right IaaS provider – AWS or GCP?

Guide to choosing the right IaaS provider – AWS or GCP?

Future of Work - Hybrid Workplace

If you’ve already moved your enterprise workloads and analytics to the cloud for faster processing and improved scalability, chances are – you’ve chosen AWS or Azure based on their market share (AWS has 32% market share and GCP is at 7% of the market as of October 2020). While both AWS and Azure both have their strengths, have you ever considered switching to the Google Cloud Platform (GCP)?

One of the key reasons why many enterprises consider GCP over AWS or Azure is its lower pricing. In this blog, we will detail the differences between Amazon Web Services (AWS) and Google Cloud Platform (GCP), both of which offers Infrastructure-as-as-Service (IaaS) – hosting and maintaining core infrastructure, including hardware, software, servers, storage, and applications in a highly scalable environment, charging customers for what they use.

In September 2020, Gartner named Google and AWS as leaders in their Infrastructure as a Service (IaaS) Magic Quadrant.

While AWS and GCP both largely offer similar basic capabilities like autoscaling, flexible compute and storage, pay-as-u-go pricing, instant provisioning, identity access management, and self-service features, there are some areas where one scores over the other.

Lower compute and storage costs – GCP

GCP’s computing and storage costs are almost 25% cheaper than AWS. Additionally, it offers a “multi-regional” cloud storage option, where the data is automatically replicated across several regions for very little added cost. Additionally, GCP offers sustained-use discounts, committed-use discounts, and discounts for reserved instances.

More solution options and accessibility – AWS

AWS has the first-mover advantage and therefore is a market leader in terms of the breadth and depth of its services it offers. AWS offers more than 175 across compute, storage, database, analytics, networking, mobile, developer tools, management tools, IoT, security, and enterprise applications, while GCP offers over 90 services. In terms of worldwide accessibility, AWS has many more data centers around the world.

AWS or GCP – What will fit your needs?

You should choose AWS over GCP if

  • You have DevOps teams who can configure and manage the infrastructure.
  • You have less time for deploying a new version of the app.
  • If your project needs high computing power.
  • If your engineers are already familiar with the programming models, operating systems, databases, and architectures.

Alternatively, GCP is preferred by many enterprises as it offers the following benefits:

  • Higher productivity through Quick Access.
  • Flexibility to work from anywhere.
  • A serverless environment to connect cloud services with a large focus mainly on the microservices architecture.
  • Long-term discounts.

Quick comparison: AWS vs. GCP

While each has its strengths and areas of improvement, the table below highlights the key differences to help you make an informed decision.

ParametersAWSAzure
ContainersAWS S3Google Cloud Storage
VM disk storageAmazon Elastic Block StorePersistent Disk (both HDD and SSD)
File storageAmazon Elastic File SystemCloud Filestore
Archive storageS3 One Zone ArchivalCloud Storage
Bulk data transferAWS is the preferred choice:
– AWS Import/Export Disk: Shipping disk drives
– AWS Snowmobile: Exabyte-scale data transfer
AWS Snowball
Nearline (low frequency)
Hybrid supportOffers managed virtual tape infrastructure for a hybrid environmentRelies on partners for hybrid support
Disaster recovery managementOffers cloud-based disaster recovery servicesOffers out-of-the-box DR or backup services
BackupAmazon S3 is used for secondary backup storageHas its own built-in Google Cloud
Serverless computingAWS LambaContainer Engine
Volume sizes500GB to 16TB1 GB to 64 TB
Max IOPS per volume500 3000 read15000 write
AI service and Machine Learning AWS has its own Al service, called SageMakerCompared to Google, the AI offering of AWS is limitedGoogle cloud used AI chips called TPU which can run TensorFlow and other AI Libraries
Networking frameworkAWS has no tiered networking frameworkGCP has its tiered networking framework
Data transmission formatIn general formatIn a fully encrypted format

Comparing both these services and choosing one over the other depends on your business needs. Research on what you need and who can address it best. If you are considering moving to AWS, Rapyder – an Advanced AWS Consulting Partner with expertise in managed Amazon cloud services, cloud migration, DevOps, and well-architected framework – can help you migrate seamlessly. To know more or discuss your cloud migration strategy, contact us.